That's exactly what i'm looking for. I've found references to those reviews, but I haven't found the reviews themselves, at least ones that aren't behind a pay wall.
ok hmmmm...... i might do sum searching for u, doubt thats a thing one'll find on torrent suites. dune-centric forums might be a good bet, dont know of any. one site that might be a long shot is scribd, i got free 1 month acces there once by linking an empty paypal acc. dont know what theyll hav. if i find something ill dm it or post here depending >.<
ok i remember ther ebeing a preface to the copy i read, by herbert's son? expalining his father's inentions with messiah, and therein references some criticism>? I mean youve probs read that but if not ill copy paste it in dms