First attempt at writing, need opinions on first 4 chapters

Loexik

Active member
Joined
Dec 14, 2020
Messages
10
Points
43
This is my first attempt at writing a LitRPG. The intention was to realise my imagination through writing. LitRPG has been a staple read for me this past year. I hope for opinions on how I can improve my story, thank you! Btw the synopsis won't be written until I've solidified my vision of what my story is to be, as any good synopsis should have some foreshadowing.

 

TheIcMan

Well-known member
Joined
May 4, 2019
Messages
31
Points
48
honestly i don't think passive voice is a problem in your work. I think you've got a nice blend between active and passive. There are some awkwardly written phrases, but 99% of what you've written is pretty good.

I like that you're hiding a good amount of things already and building mystery. If I had to nitpick something it'd be that this start is a whole bunch of walking and me not understanding who the protagonist is. The main things I got were that his stats are important, and that he's experiencing something again, with context you might deliver down the line. I don't read LitRPG's tho, so maybe that's intended? Regardless tho, it was a pretty good first chapter :blobthumbsup:
 

Loexik

Active member
Joined
Dec 14, 2020
Messages
10
Points
43
honestly i don't think passive voice is a problem in your work. I think you've got a nice blend between active and passive. There are some awkwardly written phrases, but 99% of what you've written is pretty good.

I like that you're hiding a good amount of things already and building mystery. If I had to nitpick something it'd be that this start is a whole bunch of walking and me not understanding who the protagonist is. The main things I got were that his stats are important, and that he's experiencing something again, with context you might deliver down the line. I don't read LitRPG's tho, so maybe that's intended? Regardless tho, it was a pretty good first chapter :blobthumbsup:
Yup that's the idea. Originally I was planning on giving context within the first 10k words, but it depends on the flow really.

Tbh I'm mostly worried about the 2nd chapter. Idk if it was too much fitted into the 2nd chapter or/and the MC is consistent in personality or not, and the implementation of a tiny bit military knowledge seemed awkwardly inserted. Anyways, thanks for your feedback!
Learn what passive writing is and don't use it.
If you don't mind me asking, was it in the 2nd chapter that you saw messes in my writing?
 

Lloyd

Professional Writer
Joined
Jun 2, 2020
Messages
2,358
Points
153
Yup that's the idea. Originally I was planning on giving context within the first 10k words, but it depends on the flow really.

Tbh I'm mostly worried about the 2nd chapter. Idk if it was too much fitted into the 2nd chapter or/and the MC is consistent in personality or not, and the implementation of a tiny bit military knowledge seemed awkwardly inserted. Anyways, thanks for your feedback!

If you don't mind me asking, was it in the 2nd chapter that you saw messes in my writing?
It was the first sentence so I stopped reading lol
 
Joined
Sep 2, 2020
Messages
119
Points
83
This is my first attempt at writing a LitRPG. The intention was to realise my imagination through writing. LitRPG has been a staple read for me this past year. I hope for opinions on how I can improve my story, thank you! Btw the synopsis won't be written until I've solidified my vision of what my story is to be, as any good synopsis should have some foreshadowing.

Focus on making a great characters, worldbuilding should be the least of the problem.

So don't worry about how you should write the magic system/what kind of race inhibit the world/what other dimension it have.
 

Loexik

Active member
Joined
Dec 14, 2020
Messages
10
Points
43
Focus on making a great characters, worldbuilding should be the least of the problem.

So don't worry about how you should write the magic system/what kind of race inhibit the world/what other dimension it have.
Thanks! I'll try my best to flesh out the characters well.
 

Loexik

Active member
Joined
Dec 14, 2020
Messages
10
Points
43
Is there anywhere I could maybe get a test group to review my writing before posting online?
 

ElijahRyne

A Hermit that is NOT that Lazy…
Joined
Aug 12, 2021
Messages
1,044
Points
153
This is my first attempt at writing a LitRPG. The intention was to realise my imagination through writing. LitRPG has been a staple read for me this past year. I hope for opinions on how I can improve my story, thank you! Btw the synopsis won't be written until I've solidified my vision of what my story is to be, as any good synopsis should have some foreshadowing.

(This is for the first chapter)

The first chapter is okay, yet, when reading this there are two general things I think you can do to make this better.
1. Ground your explanations. I.E. you can say that he sees a scary dog, and explain why it is so, but if add a growling sound effect before it is introduced it will sell that the dog is scary.
2. The time skips were a bit disorientating.

2 is easy to fix, either remove some of the time skips, or, for some of them, tell how much time has passed.
1 is a bit harder to explain, and I tend to overcomplicate explanations.

Here is an in text explanation for #1. (Red text will be for what is happening, orange will be for why it matters, yellow will be for how it effects, purple will be for how and making it real, and green will be suggested changes.)

Grounding a scene will allow you to put the reader in the scene. You want to do this when something new is happening, when explaining a setting/character/item/ability, and for important moments.

To ground a scene you need to know what is happening, how that effects the character(s)/setting, why what is happening matters, and to some extent how it is happening. Then you need to make it real. To do that you need to connect the scene to the reader. You can do that by establishing consequences, having a solemn momen, or anything that can make the scene matter after it is over. Here is an example:

Suzy is a small dog, her shoulders are not even a foot off the ground. She is taking a walk with her owner, Bruce. She has been limping recently, and Bruce has been worried. ‘Is she hurt?’ He wondered. It was then when Suzy tripped. She yelped in a mix of pain and surprise, as Bruce picked her up and stroked her head. “Don’t worry Suz, my little pup, I will take you to the vet, and hopefully you will no longer have that limp.

First read the original passage in its entirety.
Piercing eldrich screams echoed in the boundless dark from all directions in synchronous with unending sensations that washed over like waves of the monsoon, rapid and heavy. Meandering through contemplation, lost, so dazed that he was unaware of the manifestations in his surroundings.

Suddenly a pulsating prismatic glow replaced the present all-encompassing dark field. Despite the jarring nature of the sudden disturbance, stilled and glaze-eyed was Remus. All of it was maddening, but so lost in trance he was that he noticed not. With each burst of radiance, Remus faded ever-so-slightly until Remus was no more.
____

All there was a strong pine-like smell. Then came erratic bursts of colour, surreal blends of images contained within. Blinding flashes of light projected from innumerous angles. Multitudes of sounds came and went with no rhyme nor reason, all dissimilar to each other.

Images of bugs, birds, and rodents superposed all perception, co-occurring with ant-like ministration felt all around. Occasionally such imagery was melded with blurry shapes of vaguely miniature humanoids speaking gnomic utterances passing by subtlety in the background. All the while the body experienced impressions of being pushed, pulled, crushed, stretched, flipped, twisted, turned, bounced, and spiralled, bound to any and all possible directions in rapid sequence. Then all came to an abrupt halt, calm finally.

With a mind stuck between profundity and banality from the experience endured, it coped by scrubbing all traces of what had happened. What had happened vanished from the mind completely. What had happened was simply nothing. Remus experienced nothing but calm, for nothing happened.

"Ughh... ouch..."

Now awake, with the courtesy of a piercing headache, Remus just laid there for a while even with uneven earth under, hand pressing on his forehead. A few moments later, the headache subsided for the most part, thus prompting Remus to finally move

Now let’s add the color analysis:
Piercing eldrich screams echoed in the boundless dark from all directions in synchronous with unending sensations that washed over like waves of the monsoon, rapid and heavy. Meandering through contemplation, lost, so dazed that he was unaware of the manifestations in his surroundings.

Suddenly a pulsating prismatic glow replaced the present all-encompassing dark field.
Despite the jarring nature of the sudden disturbance, stilled and glaze-eyed was Remus. All of it was maddening, but so lost in trance he was that he noticed not. With each burst of radiance, Remus faded ever-so-slightly until Remus was no more.
____

All there was a strong pine-like smell. Then came erratic bursts of colour, surreal blends of images contained within. Blinding flashes of light projected from innumerous angles. Multitudes of sounds came and went with no rhyme nor reason, all dissimilar to each other.

Images of bugs, birds, and rodents superposed all perception, co-occurring with ant-like ministration felt all around. Occasionally such imagery was melded with blurry shapes of vaguely miniature humanoids speaking gnomic utterances passing by subtlety in the background. All the while the body experienced impressions of being pushed, pulled, crushed, stretched, flipped, twisted, turned, bounced, and spiralled, bound to any and all possible directions in rapid sequence. Then all came to an abrupt halt, calm finally.


With a mind stuck between profundity and banality from the experience endured, it coped by scrubbing all traces of what had happened. What had happened vanished from the mind completely. What had happened was simply nothing. Remus experienced nothing but calm, for nothing happened.

"Ughh... ouch..."

Now awake, with the courtesy of a piercing headache, Remus just laid there for a while even with uneven earth under, hand pressing on his forehead. A few moments later, the headache subsided for the most part, thus prompting Remus to finally move


When looking at the color version you can see that while you explained what is happening, why it is happening, and how it is happening. Yet, you have yet to connect it back to the reader. You could remove the passage and nothing much would change. The goal is to fix that. How, for this specific passage, I don’t really know how, but you could start with the “Ugh.. ouch…” part.
 
Last edited:

Loexik

Active member
Joined
Dec 14, 2020
Messages
10
Points
43
(This is for the first chapter)

The first chapter is okay, yet, when reading this there are two general things I think you can do to make this better.
1. Ground your explanations. I.E. you can say that he sees a scary dog, and explain why it is so, but if add a growling sound effect before it is introduced it will sell that the dog is scary.
2. The time skips were a bit disorientating.

2 is easy to fix, either remove some of the time skips, or, for some of them, tell how much time has passed.
1 is a bit harder to explain, and I tend to overcomplicate explanations.

Here is an in text explanation for #1. (Red text will be for what is happening, orange will be for why it matters, yellow will be for how it effects, purple will be for how and making it real, and green will be suggested changes.)

Grounding a scene will allow you to put the reader in the scene. You want to do this when something new is happening, when explaining a setting/character/item/ability, and for important moments.

To ground a scene you need to know what is happening, how that effects the character(s)/setting, why what is happening matters, and to some extent how it is happening. Then you need to make it real. To do that you need to connect the scene to the reader. You can do that by establishing consequences, having a solemn momen, or anything that can make the scene matter after it is over. Here is an example:

Suzy is a small dog, her shoulders are not even a foot off the ground. She is taking a walk with her owner, Bruce. She has been limping recently, and Bruce has been worried. ‘Is she hurt?’ He wondered. It was then when Suzy tripped. She yelped in a mix of pain and surprise, as Bruce picked her up and stroked her head. “Don’t worry Suz, my little pup, I will take you to the vet, and hopefully you will no longer have that limp.

First read the original passage in its entirety.
(spoiler=“Original“) Piercing eldrich screams echoed in the boundless dark from all directions in synchronous with unending sensations that washed over like waves of the monsoon, rapid and heavy. Meandering through contemplation, lost, so dazed that he was unaware of the manifestations in his surroundings.

Suddenly a pulsating prismatic glow replaced the present all-encompassing dark field. Despite the jarring nature of the sudden disturbance, stilled and glaze-eyed was Remus. All of it was maddening, but so lost in trance he was that he noticed not. With each burst of radiance, Remus faded ever-so-slightly until Remus was no more.
____

All there was a strong pine-like smell. Then came erratic bursts of colour, surreal blends of images contained within. Blinding flashes of light projected from innumerous angles. Multitudes of sounds came and went with no rhyme nor reason, all dissimilar to each other.

Images of bugs, birds, and rodents superposed all perception, co-occurring with ant-like ministration felt all around. Occasionally such imagery was melded with blurry shapes of vaguely miniature humanoids speaking gnomic utterances passing by subtlety in the background. All the while the body experienced impressions of being pushed, pulled, crushed, stretched, flipped, twisted, turned, bounced, and spiralled, bound to any and all possible directions in rapid sequence. Then all came to an abrupt halt, calm finally.

With a mind stuck between profundity and banality from the experience endured, it coped by scrubbing all traces of what had happened. What had happened vanished from the mind completely. What had happened was simply nothing. Remus experienced nothing but calm, for nothing happened.

"Ughh... ouch..."

Now awake, with the courtesy of a piercing headache, Remus just laid there for a while even with uneven earth under, hand pressing on his forehead. A few moments later, the headache subsided for the most part, thus prompting Remus to finally move
(/spoiler)

Now let’s add the color analysis:
(spoiler=‘color-analysis’)
Piercing eldrich screams echoed in the boundless dark from all directions in synchronous with unending sensations that washed over like waves of the monsoon, rapid and heavy. Meandering through contemplation, lost, so dazed that he was unaware of the manifestations in his surroundings.

Suddenly a pulsating prismatic glow replaced the present all-encompassing dark field.
Despite the jarring nature of the sudden disturbance, stilled and glaze-eyed was Remus. All of it was maddening, but so lost in trance he was that he noticed not. With each burst of radiance, Remus faded ever-so-slightly until Remus was no more.
____

All there was a strong pine-like smell. Then came erratic bursts of colour, surreal blends of images contained within. Blinding flashes of light projected from innumerous angles. Multitudes of sounds came and went with no rhyme nor reason, all dissimilar to each other.

Images of bugs, birds, and rodents superposed all perception, co-occurring with ant-like ministration felt all around. Occasionally such imagery was melded with blurry shapes of vaguely miniature humanoids speaking gnomic utterances passing by subtlety in the background. All the while the body experienced impressions of being pushed, pulled, crushed, stretched, flipped, twisted, turned, bounced, and spiralled, bound to any and all possible directions in rapid sequence. Then all came to an abrupt halt, calm finally.


With a mind stuck between profundity and banality from the experience endured, it coped by scrubbing all traces of what had happened. What had happened vanished from the mind completely. What had happened was simply nothing. Remus experienced nothing but calm, for nothing happened.

"Ughh... ouch..."

Now awake, with the courtesy of a piercing headache, Remus just laid there for a while even with uneven earth under, hand pressing on his forehead. A few moments later, the headache subsided for the most part, thus prompting Remus to finally move
(/spoiler)

When looking at the color version you can see that while you explained what is happening, why it is happening, and how it is happening. Yet, you have yet to connect it back to the reader. You could remove the passage and nothing much would change. The goal is to fix that. How, for this specific passage, I don’t really know how, but you could start with the “Ugh.. ouch…” part.
Awesome! I'll be refering this post for a while, hopefully it stays... Thanks!
 

Loexik

Active member
Joined
Dec 14, 2020
Messages
10
Points
43
I've just updated my fourth chapter, equaling a total of roughly 10k word written. Any feedback would be immensely helpful!
 
Top