1-2 are fine bc cat, but problem is the quality. Even i would prefer the "Anonymous" pfp than this ones.
3. Well, kinda too old style.
4. Gif pfp are not allowed. And i have a certain history of a "drama" related to it
(of a woke-karen-Scribble-user suddenly sending me a GIANT FU edited Saiki pic, when i was criticizing wokeness in movies in a thread and she crashed in like a psycho).
And the gif is also a bad one of Saiki where he is angry / Why pick frowning saiki? when you could post one of him being happy with coffee jelly^^b / Also a random user could potentially feel like you are mocking them
Edit : Seems like the 1-2 are fine. Strangely, as pfp the quality seems higher compared to posted in thread.
So yeah, revising my pick to (1) + (5)