Kilolo
I'm so kewl
- Joined
- Jul 1, 2019
- Messages
- 419
- Points
- 103
lots of people having misunderstood the thread topic isn't it? it's been a day and i rarely seen anyone who actually get it.
I'm asking for people as a READER for how far a reference could be incorrect to the point they would get annoyed, not as an AUTHOR. thus why i put this on reader general sub-forum
of course it's fine to wrote however you like, you can wrote a male giving birth, a dolphin lay eggs, or both polar bear and penguin are on the same pole. you do you, i don't care.
but what i'm asking here, as a reader, is there's really nothing that wouldn't make you get annoyed at a story for being inaccurate?
lots of people bash kantai collection anime ending because it depict as if japan actually won the world war 2, i read lots of comment of pirated manga site that they drop the manga at some point because they couldn't bear the author wrote creating communal bath in a way that very unsanitary and unhygiene. not to mention there's things about farming (where some crops can only grow in hot area or such), or nobility system with their territorial management.
i read more than i could count when there's an incorrect reference, and i just laugh off most of it. but sometimes, there's some things that painfully incorrect that makes me drop the series altogether. it just matter of taste and it is fine.
the most recent and popular example are Shuumatsu no Valkyrie, in how they wrote most of the character totally out of depiction from their popular lore. me and my friends just mostly laugh at how creative the author in making up such a character lore. but there's a time when one of us got "huh?" at some depiction and actually getting annoyed instead.
which is why I create this thread asking for personal preference as a reader, just what kind of incorrect reference i shouldn't do that some people don't like. and do i even have to say that it's fine to not liking something?
but no, most people here are being like : it's fine to wrote however you want no matter how incorrect the reference is.
I didn't ask you that. I'm asking what's the readers don't want.
I'm asking for people as a READER for how far a reference could be incorrect to the point they would get annoyed, not as an AUTHOR. thus why i put this on reader general sub-forum
of course it's fine to wrote however you like, you can wrote a male giving birth, a dolphin lay eggs, or both polar bear and penguin are on the same pole. you do you, i don't care.
but what i'm asking here, as a reader, is there's really nothing that wouldn't make you get annoyed at a story for being inaccurate?
lots of people bash kantai collection anime ending because it depict as if japan actually won the world war 2, i read lots of comment of pirated manga site that they drop the manga at some point because they couldn't bear the author wrote creating communal bath in a way that very unsanitary and unhygiene. not to mention there's things about farming (where some crops can only grow in hot area or such), or nobility system with their territorial management.
i read more than i could count when there's an incorrect reference, and i just laugh off most of it. but sometimes, there's some things that painfully incorrect that makes me drop the series altogether. it just matter of taste and it is fine.
the most recent and popular example are Shuumatsu no Valkyrie, in how they wrote most of the character totally out of depiction from their popular lore. me and my friends just mostly laugh at how creative the author in making up such a character lore. but there's a time when one of us got "huh?" at some depiction and actually getting annoyed instead.
which is why I create this thread asking for personal preference as a reader, just what kind of incorrect reference i shouldn't do that some people don't like. and do i even have to say that it's fine to not liking something?
but no, most people here are being like : it's fine to wrote however you want no matter how incorrect the reference is.
I didn't ask you that. I'm asking what's the readers don't want.