IshiharaNiaoka
Well-known member
- Joined
- Jan 8, 2022
- Messages
- 243
- Points
- 103
Text from the link
An AI detector mislabeled nearly every essay written by a non-native English speaker as being written by a bot.
In the study published Monday, the researchers ran more than 100 essays written by non-native English speakers through seven popular GPT detectors. (GPT is the framework behind some of the most widely used chatbots today, including ChatGPT.) The essays were written for an English-proficiency exam.
The researchers also fed the detectors essays written by US eighth graders who speak English natively.
More than half of the essays written by non-native English speakers were marked as AI-generated by the detection systems, the Stanford researchers found. And one GPT-detection system flagged almost 98% of those essays as written by AI.
But when evaluating essays written by eighth-grade native English speakers, the detection systems performed much better, assessing that about 20% of their essays were produced by AI. Still mislabeling human-written essays as bot-written — but not at the same rate.
The researchers warned the discrepancy could cause considerable harm to non-native English speakers who could be falsely accused of submitting work produced by chatbots for school assignments, college applications, or for work they do.
I'm bringing this up because I'm tired if some people coming to say my work is ai because it does follow the normal format of writing and a chap is flagged by an ai. Someone did this a month ago and luckily I had all my records of writing my story from 2021 to 2023.
So I was able to prove myself innocent. But it's annoying when some people still do this over and over again. I realized the chaps that don't get a percentage as ai are those that were edited by my native English friend. Yet everything ellse is a mix of ai because I'm not consistent with my writing. I'm still learning how to write as a young author so I read books I try to implement the way they write dialogues into my writing.
And at times I struggle with descriptions so I learn from descriptive writing forums where us people write descriptions and paste it on the site to help authors like me out and it's very helpful. And I'm the type of person who love descriptions. If I read a story and there's not adequate descriptions to give me a clear imagination I tend not to read it far. This is why I appreciate Chinese stories and Korean novels they really describe which is helpful but some English novels give little description something like how the character even looks ks not described at times.
So then my main message is before you go and say an author's work is ai read the entire story first. Because ai stories don't have a clear plot, that's what I realized. What's more be aware of the author's nationality. Or have concrete proof the work is ai.
Because it's very annoying for real original authors to be told their year's work is freaking ai. It's like me preparing a large family meal just for one family member to say I bought the food.
So you're trying to tell me I generated over 90 chapters of ai written text story.
It very piss of actually. Because you're judging my entire story on ai based on my writing style.
I'm a non English African writer and I'm still learning. I read books like the Witcher, some Chinese and English stories so my story witting is like a mixture for all of them. It's annoying that in order not to be repetitive I have to use writing helpers like pro writing aid free version and a bit of grammarly to bit sound repetitive. I have to always search for synonyms and antonyms of words just to no be repetitive and when I use good words it's called ai. Nice.
More links to prove my point
www.google.com
An AI detector mislabeled nearly every essay written by a non-native English speaker as being written by a bot.
In the study published Monday, the researchers ran more than 100 essays written by non-native English speakers through seven popular GPT detectors. (GPT is the framework behind some of the most widely used chatbots today, including ChatGPT.) The essays were written for an English-proficiency exam.
The researchers also fed the detectors essays written by US eighth graders who speak English natively.
More than half of the essays written by non-native English speakers were marked as AI-generated by the detection systems, the Stanford researchers found. And one GPT-detection system flagged almost 98% of those essays as written by AI.
But when evaluating essays written by eighth-grade native English speakers, the detection systems performed much better, assessing that about 20% of their essays were produced by AI. Still mislabeling human-written essays as bot-written — but not at the same rate.
The researchers warned the discrepancy could cause considerable harm to non-native English speakers who could be falsely accused of submitting work produced by chatbots for school assignments, college applications, or for work they do.
I'm bringing this up because I'm tired if some people coming to say my work is ai because it does follow the normal format of writing and a chap is flagged by an ai. Someone did this a month ago and luckily I had all my records of writing my story from 2021 to 2023.
So I was able to prove myself innocent. But it's annoying when some people still do this over and over again. I realized the chaps that don't get a percentage as ai are those that were edited by my native English friend. Yet everything ellse is a mix of ai because I'm not consistent with my writing. I'm still learning how to write as a young author so I read books I try to implement the way they write dialogues into my writing.
And at times I struggle with descriptions so I learn from descriptive writing forums where us people write descriptions and paste it on the site to help authors like me out and it's very helpful. And I'm the type of person who love descriptions. If I read a story and there's not adequate descriptions to give me a clear imagination I tend not to read it far. This is why I appreciate Chinese stories and Korean novels they really describe which is helpful but some English novels give little description something like how the character even looks ks not described at times.
So then my main message is before you go and say an author's work is ai read the entire story first. Because ai stories don't have a clear plot, that's what I realized. What's more be aware of the author's nationality. Or have concrete proof the work is ai.
Because it's very annoying for real original authors to be told their year's work is freaking ai. It's like me preparing a large family meal just for one family member to say I bought the food.
So you're trying to tell me I generated over 90 chapters of ai written text story.
It very piss of actually. Because you're judging my entire story on ai based on my writing style.
I'm a non English African writer and I'm still learning. I read books like the Witcher, some Chinese and English stories so my story witting is like a mixture for all of them. It's annoying that in order not to be repetitive I have to use writing helpers like pro writing aid free version and a bit of grammarly to bit sound repetitive. I have to always search for synonyms and antonyms of words just to no be repetitive and when I use good words it's called ai. Nice.
More links to prove my point
Programs to detect AI discriminate against non-native English speakers, shows study
Over half of essays written by people were wrongly flagged as AI-made, with implications for students and job applicants
www.google.com
Attachments
-
Screenshot_20230810-123522.jpg
Last edited:
