I think I rated two novels higher than 3. K5's work and killwrites' work. Also, Abyss Dweller by Simo wasn't in the thread, but it's the highest-rated novel so far with 4 stars.
I glanced through your reviews @greyblob , and I can't understand how you managed to rate some novels so high. A few of them have terrible writing. Typos, weird phrases, weird grammar, and one of them even had a plothole in the beginning. Yet you gave them a rating around average.
i don't care that much about typos grammar etc as long as it's not egregious. I'm rating by SH standards. 1 is unintelligible and I have one or two novels for 5.
which one has the plothole? mrgreycat's?
If you don't rate the grammar that high, then it's understandable. The plothole was in Desert something. MC was 11, then two or three years passed, and MC suddenly turned 16. Maybe it's me who missed something or misinterpreted the sentence, but the author didn't say anything. So I assume it is a mistake.
I don't remember that. it's very likely i'm the one forgetting something @Erynite write some interesting characters and you'll automatically get a high rating
It's fine. Though I think that if this keeps up we'll have to deal with ghosts coming back. Some of which were more annoying to deal with than anything.
brainwashedbrainless readers reaction to those masterpieces.