Another Generous Feedback Thread

AdOtherwise

Owl Who Reads · Hoot Hoot
Joined
Apr 8, 2023
Messages
89
Points
33
Here's the deal. I skim through your story, be as nice as possible with honest feedback and critique, and you sleep at night with miserable thoughts about your writing (maybe).

I also have a great borderwall.
1. I will NOT read SMUT.
2. I will NOT read BL, GL, or GB. NO EXCEPTIONS (unless it hasn't appeared in the story yet).
3. Referencing from Sailus' thread, choose where you want me to review your story on: DM, commenting, thread reply, etc, default is thread reply.
4. BTW, no fan fictions.

This is obvious, but post the link to your webnovel, too.

I'm a kind, encouraging angle. So I'll, by default, be kind. You get to pick how honest I'll be; ranges from kindly honest, or brutally honest. Happy writing! :blob_okay:

P.S. Don't expect me to skim through all ten of your chapters, lol. Additionally, I made this because there aren't many YUGE feedback threads, and I feel bad for other authors' new works getting ignored blatantly.
https://www.scribblehub.com/series/727045/lowly-ascent/ Thanks in advance

Webnovel: https://www.webnovel.com/book/lowly-ascent_26093747205010905###
 

shadowniy

New member
Joined
Jun 8, 2024
Messages
23
Points
3
if any one just finding out gb is gender bender i am sorry for this cursed but helpful knowledge stay informed and stay protected people
 

ATTICLover

New member
Joined
Jun 17, 2024
Messages
18
Points
3
Here's the deal. I skim through your story, be as nice as possible with honest feedback and critique, and you sleep at night with miserable thoughts about your writing (maybe).

I also have a great borderwall.
1. I will NOT read SMUT.
2. I will NOT read BL, GL, or GB. NO EXCEPTIONS (unless it hasn't appeared in the story yet).
3. Referencing from Sailus' thread, choose where you want me to review your story on: DM, commenting, thread reply, etc, default is thread reply.
4. BTW, no fan fictions.

This is obvious, but post the link to your webnovel, too.

I'm a kind, encouraging angle. So I'll, by default, be kind. You get to pick how honest I'll be; ranges from kindly honest, or brutally honest. Happy writing! :blob_okay:

P.S. Don't expect me to skim through all ten of your chapters, lol. Additionally, I made this because there aren't many YUGE feedback threads, and I feel bad for other authors' new works getting ignored blatantly.

Well here's mine. Though you cannot see the full premise of what I'm trying to write yet because I'm writing a prologue so I'm still cooking up how I'm going to integrate that last half in my synopsis before I start the actual story. Thanks
 
Last edited:

ArvinMateo23

New member
Joined
Jun 20, 2024
Messages
1
Points
3
Hello! 😁
Good afternoon! (I might be wrong, Sorry)
It would my pleasure if you were to read my writing!

I am currently 19, and, a newbie, but still had fun writing this story regardless!

Would it be ok for you to read it and give it a brutally honest critique or feedback.


This is a story setting place in HEAVEN
 
Last edited:

raytides

New member
Joined
Jun 26, 2024
Messages
4
Points
3
Here's the deal. I skim through your story, be as nice as possible with honest feedback and critique, and you sleep at night with miserable thoughts about your writing (maybe).

I also have a great borderwall.
1. I will NOT read SMUT.
2. I will NOT read BL, GL, or GB. NO EXCEPTIONS (unless it hasn't appeared in the story yet).
3. Referencing from Sailus' thread, choose where you want me to review your story on: DM, commenting, thread reply, etc, default is thread reply.
4. BTW, no fan fictions.

This is obvious, but post the link to your webnovel, too.

I'm a kind, encouraging angle. So I'll, by default, be kind. You get to pick how honest I'll be; ranges from kindly honest, or brutally honest. Happy writing! :blob_okay:

P.S. Don't expect me to skim through all ten of your chapters, lol. Additionally, I made this because there aren't many YUGE feedback threads, and I feel bad for other authors' new works getting ignored blatantly.
It's really kind of you to do this! I would really appreciate some feedback if you're still open to check another story out: https://www.scribblehub.com/series/1133422/

Please feel free to be as brutally honest as you want to be. By that I mean you can go full Gordon Ramsey of literature on my writing and I will thank you for it LOL
 
Top