Sakai Yuji had always aspired to control his own destiny and write his own story. One day, he found himself transported to a new world, one in which magic and cultivators were very real. Upon discovering that beast could speak, humans could fly, and immortals could live forever, Sakai Yuji...
www.scribblehub.com
Please review this book. You can just post on the thread.
Sorry for taking so much time to write this feedback, at first I was busy with stuff and then I got lazy. Obligatory reminder that English is my second language, and this is subjective feedback from a reader. I stopped reading after I finished
Chapter 1 : New world
Two things I have to mention before I start the feedback. The first is a friendly advice. If you write such short chapters, your average words per chapter is 1,266, you have to update more frequently.
The second, why would you use a Japanese name(MC?)? Sure, I won't deduct points in your case since it doesn't matter now, but it makes me question your choice even more.
Okay, with this out of the way, let me start my feedback. There is a fair share of different grammar and technical mistakes. And from what I've seen after quickly skimming through your last chapter, you didn't fix it.
The first thing isn't necessarily a mistake, but you should make a decision. Do you want to use double space between your paragraphs or not? Using double space to separate certain things, for example, the start of a new day, in a chapter, is okay. It's not okay to randomly change the space between the paragraphs since formatting is important. Personally, I like it when there is a single space, but you do you.
Speaking of formatting issues.
“ You alive?”
“ Want some”
The above are just a few examples, there are a lot more, and you didn't fix it in the latest chapter, so, I assume you didn't fix it at all.
You make random capitalizations.
As he looking around himself to confirm if he was
truly Kicked
Yuji take his time
and Analyzed
“So, this is how it is” Yuji
said In a low voice,
he Can’t
Again, these are examples. It doesn't mean that there are no more similar mistakes.
The opposite has also happened.
What the hell is this?
a gaming character sheet” Yuji exclaimed in shock. You didn't capitalize the start of a new sentence. Though in this case, this is the only one I noticed. Maybe there are more, but I didn't notice more.
This sentence actually has yet another mistake.
What the hell is this? a gaming character shee
t” Yuji exclaimed in shock.
And here is one more sentence with the same mistake.
“ Why? Why always m
e” He scream
Where is the exclamation mark? In fact, where are any punctuation marks at all? Like, a question mark? A full stop\dot, a comma, anything. These examples are a perfect explanation of your mistake since you can understand what kind of punctuation mark you need. But there are also these sentences.
“His pulse increasi
ng”
“ Well well, don’t get over excided now Yuji, let’s first understand the syst
em” This sentence, on top of no punctuation mark, also has the same formatting issue as I mentioned above.
You have severe tense problems.
Through this entrance of the shelter
he saw the tilting
sun that slowly vanishing in the horizon
This sentence is a good example to illustrate that you have to stick to one tense. Use one tense in descriptions, expositions, and so on. Use different tenses when you write dialogue lines. That's it.
And now, I will show all kinds of mistakes that were mostly in a single instance.
But all of his drea
m s shattered Typo.
If god not pulling a prank on him then what is it
?. Typo?
But soon
a realizing donned onto Yuji. Wrong word. Should be realization.
He shift
his gaze focus No need for two words here, either one is okay, while two don't make sense.
“ What was that noise
? “Where am I?” Formatting issues and too many quotation marks.
goa
t’s lot’s of goa
t’s everywhere. No need for apostrophes, and you missed a comma.
A couple of examples from the latest chapter.
“ They tried to brake the wall but faile
d” answered Yuji
“Anything els
e”
“Did you noticed anything els
e” Wise one repeat his question.
he doesn’t wants to be seen as rude goat so he said senior
. This one isn't edited. It's probably a typo.
With grammar mostly out of the way, I can talk a little bit about the actual story, right? Well, obviously not, since I've read only one chapter. But this one chapter has left me dissatisfied. There is no story. Yes, this is an isekai, and yes you have all kinds of backstories and future revelations and whatnot, but I simply don't like how you wrote the first chapter. It has no emotions.
Take the very first couple of paragraphs, the ones about the hospital. They are hollow, they don't add a thing. If you cut them out, you won't lose anything. The reason for that is partially your writing.
“His pulse increasing”
“We’re losing him,” says a doctor.
This is freaking dry as hell. I understand that surgeons or whatever doctor it is are used to patients dying and they won't scream at the top of their lungs for every dying person. I understand this. But not to the point that there are NO emotions shown.
Especially, after you write this.
and a few doctors and nurses are trying everything they can to keep him alive. Moreover, this is fiction, and they talk about MC. Add at least a little bit in a dialogue line or a dialogue tag.
Anyway, you might argue that this part is necessary to justify MC talking about the hospital later on. Nope. It isn't necessary. We can guess what happened from this.
As he struggled to breath he looked around, but to his surprise he wasn’t greeted by the lights of the hospital nor by the angry nurse
And there are a lot more instances when you write something that doesn't matter, while not mentioning things that will help me bond with MC and care about him. It's not about short chapters, it's about focusing on the wrong sentences.
And this is it. I didn't find any good parts, sorry. No, there was one. I understand and comprehend what you write. I rate this highly. However, it wasn't pleasant to read, and there was no story. Is your story atrocious? No. But it needs a lot of work. Moreover, if you fix at least technical\grammar issues and are somehow able to post more chapters, I believe you will achieve at least a relative popularity.
As for the story part, well, it was my subjective opinion. Maybe others will like it more? I don't know. What I want to say is, fix the formatting\typos. Those are objective. As for everything else, ask for more feedback before acting. As usual, I didn't rate your novel, but if I had to, 1.75 stars. If you have any questions feel free to ask me. If I can, I will answer them.