Now, I've seen some people with hundreds of books on their reading lists. For me, 5 books already feels like a LOT, so I don't understand how some people can do 20 or more. You'd have to remember characters, details about the world, abilities, and plot points. How can anyone follow so many stories at the same time?
I have always had a good memory for stories. Growing up in a difficult environment, there were many different "stories" one had to keep straight. Mix them up? Earn a beating.
I will remember the gist of a story decades after reading it. Thus, to differentiate "proper" literature and popular fiction I need only read a book twice. Should I learn something new or be surprised a second time, it can be considered literature.
There are very few books I have read more than twice, and those I consider gems.
I do not use the site's reading list but a folder with simple txt files. They includes all books I've ever read, am reading, and, for all read after 2016, when I read them.
Can I recite their plot just by reading the title? For about one fifth of those books that is indeed the case.
As for the other four fifths, for half of them I can recall the complete plot by reading their summary. For the other two fifths, for all but a few of those, I would need to re-read a few chapters and that would be enough for me to remember the gist of the plot. Of course, there are a few works of fiction I read while drunk or sleep deprived. I might not remember those at all.
As for webnovels, I read in bulk. Even if I am a bit hazy on the plot, all I need to do is backtrack two chapters or read the first two chapters again. Most worlds are very similar. The featured characters and abilities fit in some mold. There is not as much to remember as one would think.
Of course, this makes any truly unique world, character, and magic system all the more memorable.
In a sense, is the world not a collection of stories? Can you remember your mates and their stories? Keep track of their changing girlfriends and jobs? Remember their childhood stories and drunk escapades? That time during the chaotic last years of the Soviet Union they went to Камчатка, met some "business men" and ate a bear's heart together? What about your own stories? I believe most people have hundreds of stories to tell.
[...]
you remember key details. thats what filters a good novel from a bad one. sometimes i read a novel only to realize on chapter 20 that i've read this before already.
Good point. This has happened to me as well.
As for why this happens, if the first few chapters are very common, they may seem familiar.
Nonetheless, one cannot be certain that they've read a story before just based on a sense of familiarity. Many novels are extremely similar. It may take me twenty chapters to be certain that I, indeed, know the novel.