Is this story good enough?

YukiTheGhost

Active member
Joined
Apr 27, 2021
Messages
9
Points
43
I’ve had a story idea sitting in the back of my head for a while now, but I don’t know if it’s good enough to become a full-fledged story.
MC is a Japanese teenager named Ryosuke Shoichiro. His childhood friend invites him to meet her at the park. When he gets there, he sees her lovely face being bitten off by a giant monster. A clan of monster slayers rescues him and tells him the only way to bring her back to life is to feed her the blood of the clan leaders sister which the clan leader promised to protect. Clan leader does know if she should break the promise though because if she does chlid hood friend lives.
criticism is welcome.
 

SailusGebel

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 7, 2020
Messages
9,414
Points
233
I’ve had a story idea sitting in the back of my head for a while now, but I don’t know if it’s good enough to become a full-fledged story.
MC is a Japanese teenager named Ryosuke Shoichiro. His childhood friend invites him to meet her at the park. When he gets there, he sees her lovely face being bitten off by a giant monster. A clan of monster slayers rescues him and tells him the only way to bring her back to life is to feed her the blood of the clan leaders sister which the clan leader promised to protect. Clan leader does know if she should break the promise though because if she does chlid hood friend lives.
criticism is welcome.
Everything is good enough to become a full-fledged story. There are no boundaries(except for the platform rules) in writing. Can you please elaborate more on what kind of answer you expect? What do you want to know? An opinion from the side? Or for example, if this story has any chance to be popular? What do you mean when you say good? Also, it's not a story but a premise\synopsis.
 

ArcadiaBlade

I'm a Lazy Writer, So What?
Joined
Dec 23, 2018
Messages
886
Points
133
Every story is good, only if your skilled enough to make it good. If you want to write it, then go ahead, no one really wants to stop you here in being creative. The only bad ones are those that are intentionally write it bad and as long as you became good at writing, you only need to make it good for a story to become one.
 

Lloyd

Professional Writer
Joined
Jun 2, 2020
Messages
2,358
Points
153
If you have to ask it isn't good enough.
 

Blackout

Worshipper of Chin Chin the Dark Lord
Joined
Mar 28, 2020
Messages
144
Points
83
1. Both Ryosuke and Shoichiro are given names. You might want to change one of them
2. Why would the clan member(s) tell the MC the secret to save his childhood friend? That's basically betrayal on their part. You might want to change it to a random stranger.
3. "Clan leader does know if she should break the promise though": I don't really get this part. please explain.
 

Agentt

Thighs
Joined
Oct 8, 2020
Messages
3,428
Points
183
I have made a story on squidward reincarnated as Cinderella, so you get it, right?
 

YukiTheGhost

Active member
Joined
Apr 27, 2021
Messages
9
Points
43
Step 1 is to not annoy others by talking on someone else's thread
I don’t mind
1. Both Ryosuke and Shoichiro are given names. You might want to change one of them
2. Why would the clan member(s) tell the MC the secret to save his childhood friend? That's basically betrayal on their part. You might want to change it to a random stranger.
3. "Clan leader does know if she should break the promise though": I don't really get this part. please explain.
Who to change to a random person
I also have another idea. It’s basically SCP foundation but instead of anomalies being kept inside there would be children with supernatural powers.
 
Last edited:

KoyukiMegumi

Kitty
Joined
Jun 11, 2021
Messages
898
Points
133
Step 1 is to not annoy others by talking on someone else's thread
:blob_teary: Yes, Shujin-sama.
I don’t mind

Who to change to a random person
I also have another idea. It’s basically SCP foundation but instead of anomalies being kept inside there would be children with supernatural powers.
:blob_aww:They don't mind, Shujin-sama!

The topic at hand, maybe write out the first chapter to clarify ideas, because it sounds a little odd unless you are going for chosen one story.
Maybe we could give you better feedback on the story if you do that.
But every story is worth writing imo.
 

Ai-chan

Queen of Yuri Devourer of Traps
Joined
Dec 23, 2018
Messages
1,413
Points
153
I’ve had a story idea sitting in the back of my head for a while now, but I don’t know if it’s good enough to become a full-fledged story.
MC is a Japanese teenager named Ryosuke Shoichiro. His childhood friend invites him to meet her at the park. When he gets there, he sees her lovely face being bitten off by a giant monster. A clan of monster slayers rescues him and tells him the only way to bring her back to life is to feed her the blood of the clan leaders sister which the clan leader promised to protect. Clan leader does know if she should break the promise though because if she does chlid hood friend lives.
criticism is welcome.
Which one is supposed to be his surname? Both Ryosuke and Shoichiro are given names, not surnames.

Japanese names have given name and surname, just like westerners. However, unlike westerners, Japanese names have no middle names. It's always two: given name and surname. No Japanese name will ever have three names.

Westerners generally assume that Japanese names start with surname, then given name, but this is not always true. When written in Japanese, the surname is always first. When written in English, it follows western convention, which is given name goes first.

For example, Ai-chan's name in English is Airi Shiina, which follows the western convention, which is given name first and surname second. But in Japanese, Ai-chan's name is 椎名愛李 written in furigana as しいなあいり (Shiina Airi). A given name can be written in either kanji or hiragana, but a surname is always written in kanji. 椎名 means 'distinguished oak' referring to 'a strong tree respected for its contributions' but can also mean 'a strong, unmoving personage whose feet holds strong against the wind'.

You would've saved yourself a lot of time and headache if you just use English names. But Ai-chan understands if you want to get out of your comfort zone and try something new. While most modern Japanese names no longer have meaning, parents still name their children hoping they'd grow up following the meaning of their name. At the very least, you need to know the formatting of Japanese names if you want to use them.

Japanese names in general do not have gender attached to them and are mostly gender neutral, though some names are attached to one gender more often. For example, Kaoru is used to name both male and female, but Kaoruko is always female. Similarly, Yuki can be both male and female name, but Yukiko is always female and Yukio is always male.

You can't really just invent a new surname either as most native Japanese surnames was archived in the Meiji era.

An easy way to construct a Japanese name if you don't care about meaning is to look at the names of your favourite pornstars, artists or anime characters and mix and match their names. You just need to know which one is the surname and which one is the given name. While Ai-chan did say the given name is mentioned first in English, not everyone follow this rule, either due to confusion or plain stubbornness.
 

K5Rakitan

Level 34 👪 💍 Pronouns: she/whore ♀
Joined
Apr 15, 2020
Messages
8,279
Points
233
Sounds like a great start!
 
Top